We Need to Talk about Johnny

Johnny Horne has been one of the most intriguing characters in Twin Peaks since the beginning for me. I always wanted to know more about his story as I feel there is so much more to him than meets the eye.

In Mark Frost’s The Final Dossier it is confirmed that Johnny has severe autism. Autism back in the late 80’s was nowhere near as understood as it is today, and diagnoses were much less common so it is easy to see why this was not discussed early on. I am a mother of a son who also has autism and severe learning difficulties so it’s perhaps obvious then that I would take a particular interest in him.

Johnny was born into a somewhat dysfunctional family. His father had little interest in him and I would imagine even less once his disability became more apparent as he grew up.  Ben Horne is, or at least was, the kind of man who needed his son to take on the family business and when it became obvious that this was never going to happen I suspect this was the end of any real father and son relationship between them. He could not be proud of him; he was a blight on the family name.

The Horne family having an uncomfortable dinner at home in the Great NorthernHis mother Sylvia was perhaps equally awful, though she did pay more attention to him. It appears she was left with sole responsibility for his care, which for her, being a woman of wealth meant that she paid other people to do it. She seemed pretty exasperated with the whole situation from very early on, and in no way am I defending her behaviour but I do get how difficult it can be. Sylvia just could not deal with the cards she had been dealt in life, but perhaps she did the best she possibly could.

It’s easy to place the blame on others when something unexpected happens to your baby.  It’s part and parcel of grieving for the child you imagined you’d have. In this particular case Sylvia blamed Audrey for Johnny’s problems, for Audrey pushed him down the stairs. This was revealed in a deleted scene of the Definitive Gold Box Edition released in 2007. Audrey was a toddler when this happened yet Sylvia could not distinguish that any malice shown by Audrey in those moments was the act of an undeveloped child, still learning her way in the world, not an adult making a rational or reasoned decision. She never forgave her daughter it seems, their relationship greatly strained throughout their lives and in the process she lost not one but two of the children she imagined she’d have.

Johnny’s relationship with his sister is not greatly elaborated on in the series though Audrey comments that she loved Laura for taking care of her brother, something she obviously felt she could not do herself, but was glad that Laura took the time for him. Audrey herself was well aware of her own ’emotional problems’ telling Cooper on their first meet that they ‘run in the family’.

Johnny Horne wearing a Native American headdress in a play room of toys

Johnny really did love Laura and she really did love him. She wrote in her diary that she liked being there for him as he loved her no matter what she did – she must have told him of her escapades as he wouldn’t have experienced anything like them himself, and he must have listened intently and without judgement.  Laura understood Johnny more than she did a lot of people. She would no doubt have treated him not like the child that most people did, but with a kindness, a nurturing friendship, an honesty. She saw in him something that perhaps no-one else cared to look for. I totally get this, for it is not until you know someone with autism that you really understand that there is way more going on in their world, you can only really get to see this if you’re lucky enough to be able to look into their eyes long enough to see their soul. They glisten like jewels.

Laura also brought something special out in Johnny. In my mind it was her pure white light that he could see.

Excerpt from the Secret Diary of Laura Palmer:

Before I could get up, Johnny took hold of my hands and smiled one of his biggest smiles ever. He closed his eyes, reopened them and said his very first sentence! He said, ‘I love you, Laura.’ I could go on and on about how wonderful that was, both as an incredible leap for him, as well as for me. It was the highest compliment I have ever been given”.

Dr Jacoby believed that Johnny chose to regress to childhood as a means to escape a trauma which happened to him as a child. We may never know what that trauma was but it leads me to believe that Johnny may have seen something from ‘the other world’. Maybe he stepped into the Black Lodge and couldn’t handle what he saw there and shied away from growing up, bottling himself up in his own world.  Maybe his mind never left the Black Lodge – and maybe he’s sending clues to us without anyone even realising.

Knowing now the fate of Annie Blackburn, her behaviour is not dissimilar to that of Johnny’s and we know she visited the Black Lodge with catastrophic effect on her psyche. She sends a message but once a year to tell the world she’s ‘fine’.

Similarly, the few scenes of Johnny Horne tell a tale, it’s almost as if he’s trying to give the people around him clues or reenacting important moments from the past.  As a younger man he dressed in a Native American headdress/war bonnet. Yes of course it would be common for a child to play dressing up, ‘Cowboys and Indians’, and especially so in Twin Peaks, a town with such ripe Native American history. He would have absorbed the imagery splashed around the town, but maybe he did link into that history more than we can understand. Could he tap into the time when the Nez Perce tribe lived where Twin Peaks the town now stands, at the time when evil first started to rear its ugly head?

Johnny Horne dressed as a Native American, firing a toy crossbow

Johnny was distraught when Laura did not turn up for his regular tutoring session.  Whilst it was explained away as him not dealing with the change to his routine, I firmly believe he knew she was gone.  He spent the day banging his head against the doll’s house, staring in through the miniature window as if he knew that something had gone on in Laura’s house, her childhood snatched from her too by the man under the ceiling fan.

In all fairness to Dr Jacoby he was one of the few people who did treat Johnny with a kindness and affection, he knew that he needed comforting, though gave up on trying to help him, deciding he just chose to be that way. He might be right about that, and I don’t think it’s any coincidence that “Charmaine” by the Mantovani Orchestra is played during the very disturbing scene of Richard Horne assaulting and robbing his grandmother in Series 3. This track is synonymous with the film One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest  in which the narrator, the schizophrenic Native American Chief Bromden, is incarcerated in a mental institution, assumed to be deaf and mute, but turns out to be neither. People’s assumptions of him put him in a position of power, as a non cooperative player he gets to observe and absorb the secrets spoken in his presence. Were Lynch/Frost trying to tell us something about Johnny with this choice of music?

Jacoby managed to prise the headdress off him so that he could attend Laura’s funeral. Johnny clutched an antique copy of the book Peter Pan, which of course is a hint that he was a child trapped in a man’s body, never wanting to grow up. Johnny never spoke, but like many people with autism – can, just choose not to. My son included. The one word Johnny uttered throughout all 3 Series’ was “Amen!” at the end of the service. He meant that, he wanted her to be at peace. He wanted her trauma to be over.

Johnny Horne clutches a copy of Peter Pan at Laura Palmer's funeral

In later years Johnny’s condition does not appear to have improved at all. Without the nurture, care and attention that Laura gave him it is unlikely he ever will.  In series 3 we first saw him running throughout the massive wood adorned home he shared with his mother. They no longer reside with his father Ben, post divorce.  It appears his nurse Mary has taken her eye of the ball and he has escaped his room.  At a hundred miles per hour he runs through the house and head first into a wall, knocking off a framed picture of the Great Falls that his father’s hotel overlooks.

The second I saw this scene I thought that he was trying to tell us something, and not just that he wanted to escape his private prison in whatever way he could. Dressed in the same shade of blue as the pyjamas Doppelcooper wore upon his escape from the Black Lodge, in the infamous, “How’s Annie?” scene, it’s as if he plays out the moment his head smashed against the mirror.  Unfortunately he doesn’t understand his own strength.  Did he aim for that picture? In hindsight we know that there was ‘something’ at the Great Northern, a sound lingering in the air that they couldn’t quite place. In the basement was the entrance to The Dutchman’s that Cooper would take to meet Jeffries and ultimately save Laura, something Johnny would have wanted more than anything in the world.  Even after all this time. For whether Johnny has a foot in the other world or not there’s one thing I know, he won’t forget a thing, he’ll be meticulous and his love for the people who really cared for him will stay with him forever.

Johnny quite possibly never had another relationship, a friend even, like Laura.  He was contained within four walls, and after his self-imposed head injury he was imprisoned further, for ‘his own safety’ by being tied to a chair, his jaw wired and forced to stare at what is without doubt the most disturbing teddy bear even created. I have tried to see a good intention for what Sylvia did to him here but I just can’t. The bear questions him, “Hello Johnny, how are you today?” over and over again, it’s mouth filled with god only knows what, definitely some human teeth stuck in there, (quite probably Johnny’s own) a glowing orb blinks as it speaks.

Johnny's teddy bear with a glass globe head, teeth and glowing light

I couldn’t help but think that this was a dig at the manufacturers of educational toys made for people with special needs, I have seen enough utter trash in my five years as a mother that is supposed to help my son’s progress, invented by quacks for a quick buck with no evidence to back up their claims. When all Johnny ever really needed was someone to sit down with him and converse, to not yell at him. To look into his eyes, see his soul, understand that there is a real person in there, he’s not a nuisance or a burden, his life matters.

Sylvia does show concern for him when he hurts himself, there is a love in there for him, it’s just she cannot direct it properly. It’s like the natural instinct to scold your child when they do something dangerous like run out into the street without looking. The fear of losing them creates such a storm of emotion that fear is misplaced with anger. This is what Sylvia did to Johnny after his self harming episode, but with an element of callous cruelty – putting a plate of colourful and enticing cookies that he couldn’t possibly eat, right under his nose.

It doesn’t stop him from loving her though. When Richard turns up at the house and carries out the horrific attack on his grandmother Johnny does everything in his power to break free – I feel he wanted to protect his mother, he wasn’t scared of Richard, was not concerned for his personal safety, he just wanted to keep her safe.  When Richard finally leaves, Sylvia’s first concern is Johnny.

And so the story repeats itself as many do in the world of Twin Peaks, especially those of mothers and their children. Like Shelly followed in her mothers footsteps and Becky continued the trend of choosing the absolute worst men, Audrey Horne continues Sylvia’s theme.  A mother herself now to a wayward son of a totally different kind, perhaps unable to cope with his behavioural issues and driven to breakdown. Richard too appears to hold his mother dear, following the dangerous man he had seen only in a picture kept by his mother, intrigue taking over and perhaps the need to have his father in his life (that is assuming that Audrey told him what happened to her and assuming she knew herself).

Many people will scoff at the idea that Johnny had anything more going on than whats was shown on the surface, but I’d like to tell those people that maybe they should go and meet someone like him. They may just end up learning more about life, how the mind really works, what the soul looks like. It’s a beautiful thing to witness, and is not something to be feared. In the end we all just need the same thing in life – to be loved.


Written by Laura Stewart

Laura is the Assistant Editor-In-Chief, a Writer and Assistant to the Webmaster at 25YL. She has been part of the team since May 2017 when she began writing about her favourite TV show of all time: Twin Peaks. She currently oversees the Film, Music and Gaming Departments. 25YL is her passion project and is constantly delighted at how big and beautiful it has grown.

Laura lives by the sea in Gower, Wales, with her husband and very special little boy.

2 Pings & Trackbacks

  1. Pingback:

  2. Pingback:

Leave a Reply

Bill Pullman as Fred in Lost Highway

Learn Lynch: Lost Highway

Melinda Carnival of souls

The Proto-Lynchian Unease of Carnival of Souls